The Great Debate: Which Way Do You Swing?

Written by Travis Mattern from Fitness Education Online

Which way do you swing? That’s an important question right? But it is maybe not quite the question you think it is, because I’m talking about the kettlebell swing. Get your mind out of the gutter, what were you thinking?

If you’ve been around gyms, CrossFit boxes, bootcamps and fitpros on the gram you’ll see people doing the kettlebell swing. What you’ll notice is that there are a couple of key ways to complete the swing; the Russian Swing or the American Swing. Seems pretty straight forward by the name, where each originated. But, kettlebells have been used by the Russian Special Forces, Strongmen and Athletes since at least the 1700s! Whereas, kettlebells hit popularity in North America in the 90’s thanks to the great Pavel Tsatsouline.

So what’s the difference?

In a nutshell, the big difference is how high you will be swinging the kettlebell. The Russian Kettlebell swing will stop at about chest height, whereas the American Swing will stop with the arms locked out overhead.

The Great Debate: Which Way Do You Swing?

So what are two different options? Well, let’s first understand the purpose of the kettlebell swing. There are many different reasons someone might be adding swings to their workout routine, these might include;

  •         Conditioning
  •         Developing explosive power from the hips
  •         Muscle recruitment of the core and posterior chain
  •         Balance
  •         Posture

As you can see, there are plenty of good reasons to complete a kettlebell swing. So, the next question is, what are the reasons to complete the American Kettlebell swing?

  •         Greater range of motion (ROM)
  •         Better standard of where the movement is complete
  •         Greater ROM = harder work

Realistically, that’s the best I could come up with and each of these reasons are essentially derived from CrossFit. The general CrossFit theory is that a Russian Swing is considered a ‘half rep’, why not complete it overhead? If you increase ROM we’re working harder and finally, the finish point of arms overhead by the ears is a nice standard to count reps. This theory however falls apart, because if you never do ‘partial’ repetitions deadlifting would be obsolete because you should only ever be cleaning.

So, if you’re not a cross fitter, should you be doing the American Swing?

No and here’s why;

  •         For a lot of people (me included), we’re just not mobile enough to complete the movement safely. For me to be able to hold my hands essentially together and put them overhead beside my ears, without compensating somewhere down the chain, it is (currently) near impossible for me (I say currently, because I hope one day I’ll be able to improve my mobility to be able to do it). But, I know I’m not alone with this restriction. Then, add in a 16kg weight, it just isn’t worth it (I’ll give some alternatives later).
  •         It takes it away from what it is supposed to be, an explosive hip hinge movement and makes people bring into play their shoulders more to ‘pull’ the bell up overhead. Again, doing this with an 8kg bell may not be an issue for many people, but try it with a 32kg bell (or don’t).
  •         Essentially, to do the movement correctly you’ll have to use a light weight, which will challenge the shoulders, but not the big muscle groups of the hips, glutes and hamstrings.

So, if you’re not American Swinging what can you do instead? Well to me, there are essentially two much better alternatives to swinging the bell overhead.

  •         The first would be to do heavier Russian Swings. Remember the general goal of the swing is to develop power, what better way to do this than being able to move more weight explosively. For me, one of the best cues to help someone become more explosive and powerful is by giving them a much heavier bell (provided their technique is sound), because there is NO way they can rely on their arms to swing the bell.
  •         The second exercise is the kettlebell snatch. This serves the purpose of completing a swing to fully overhead, but with a much lower risk of injury. Part of the reason for this is that it is a single arm movement. This allows for your body to move and rotate as both hands aren’t locking in together holding the bell. For novices the snatch is a pretty complicated and scary movement, which can be uncomfortable if you’ve not learnt how to complete it correctly. My advice is practice the single arm swing and single arm high pull to help pattern the snatch. Then study, get a coach, reach a book, do a course, or all of them to break down and learn the movement.

So to sign off, which way do you swing and why? Are you a CrossFit competitor or have you just been taught by someone who has learnt kettlebells through that environment. 

Thank you for checking out  Fitness Education Online Blog!

Fitness Education Online are one of the leading providers in the world when it comes to the professional development of Personal Trainers. We have over 30 registered CEC courses Click here to check them out.

Feel free to join our Free Facebook Group with over 14 000 other Fitness Professionals Click here to Join

 

Travis is the co-founder and director at Fitness Education Online. Fitness Education Online is one of the leading organisations in the world when it comes to providing CEC courses for Personal Trainers.

 

Travis is the co founder and director at Fitness Education Online. Fitness Education Online are one of the leading organisations in the world when it comes to providing CEC courses for Personal Trainers. Check out their website below to see their range of Fitness Australia registered courses.

0 Comments

Get In Touch With Us

Related Articles

Themed Workout

Themed Workout

When you have your clients showing up to your sessions day in and day out, it should be pretty clear that they are getting something out of it that is of benefit to them. They either love your style of training, you as a trainer/friend, their team mates or maybe the...

Accumulator Workout for Large Groups!

Accumulator Workout for Large Groups!

A super effective, bodyweight only session which works perfectly for large groups and if you have limited equipment. As the name suggests, its all about accumulating as many reps as we can in 20 minutes, similar to an AMRAP but adding 3 reps on to each round.  I like...

Warm up for Bootcamp

Warm up for Bootcamp

A great 5 - 10 minute warm up for bootcamp to improve our muscles dynamics so we are less inclined to injury, prepare us for the rigors of exercise. And getting a light sweat on without fatigue is key in our group sessions, but it also helps to get both ourselves and...